Loading…
Loading…
Loading…
Edexcel GCSE Geography A · 1GA0
Edexcel 1GA0 · 5.6 Development Case Study: Influencing Factors Check the specification (PDF) (opens in a new tab)
India is an emerging country whose economy has shifted from a strong dependence on primary activities towards services and knowledge-based activities. This is a change in its economic structure: the relative importance of different types of work and production.
The primary sector obtains raw materials, for example through farming. The secondary sector makes goods and includes construction. The tertiary sector provides services, while the quaternary sector involves knowledge-based work such as information technology and research. Quaternary activities are often counted within broader service-sector figures, so they should not automatically be added to tertiary figures as a separate total.
These changes can increase national income and create new opportunities, but their benefits are not shared equally between workers or regions.
Agriculture’s contribution to India’s GDP has fallen from 37.2% to 14.5%. GDP measures the value of production, so this shows that agriculture has become less important relative to the rest of the economy. It does not, by itself, show that India produces less food.
Farming has also become more mechanised. Machinery can complete tasks more quickly and increase output per worker, but it can reduce the need for agricultural labour. People seeking alternative employment may move from rural areas to towns and cities.
This rural-to-urban migration can give workers access to a wider range of jobs. However, it can also separate family members and disrupt traditional family units. Agricultural change therefore brings potential productivity gains alongside social costs for rural communities.
India’s secondary sector has expanded through industrialisation, although its growth has been relatively slow. Factories create employment and turn raw materials into higher-value products. This provides another source of income beyond farming.
Industrial growth also has negative impacts. Rising air pollution can damage environmental quality, while the concentration of employment in urban areas increases population density and pressure on infrastructure.
The location of growth matters. If investment and new jobs are concentrated in already successful core regions, poorer peripheral regions benefit less. Industrialisation can therefore increase national wealth while widening the development gap within India.
Services have grown rapidly: their contribution to GDP has increased from 45.8% to 67.1%. Service-sector expansion creates jobs and contributes to rising national income. These activities range from low-paid everyday services to highly skilled professional work, so growth does not mean that every new job is well paid.
India has also developed knowledge-based activities. Its telecommunications market has grown rapidly, it has significant space and satellite programmes, and information and communication technology has created over one million jobs. These activities attract investment from TNCs and create opportunities for skilled workers.
However, the benefits depend on access to suitable skills and on where employers locate. TNC-led formal employment has grown particularly in core regions, so workers and places outside these areas may gain less. Meanwhile, demand for low-paid, low-skilled services has increased informal employment. Such work can provide an income, but workers may lack employment benefits and it does not directly generate tax revenue in the same way as registered employment.
Investment means spending on assets, infrastructure or skills to generate future benefits. India’s development involves both public investment by government and private investment by businesses.
Before 1991, private investment faced significant restrictions: companies needed a licence before they could build and begin producing goods. In 1991, the government began opening up the economy, making it easier for private businesses to invest.
Large investors from the USA and Europe subsequently outsourced manufacturing and IT services to India. Outsourcing means arranging for another business or location to carry out work. TNCs established offices and production plants, increasing the role of private investment in India’s development.
Private investment can create jobs, provide training and improve infrastructure. Formal businesses also pay taxes, giving government money that can support further development. However, competition for jobs is high, and some of the most desirable positions may be filled by workers from a TNC’s home country. Investment concentrated in core regions also risks reinforcing regional inequalities.
The increased role of private businesses has not removed the need for public investment. India retains a large public sector and invests in education, healthcare, transport and housing. It has also committed to investment in renewable energy, including solar power, and to planting more forests to absorb carbon emissions.
Public and private investment can support each other. Government-funded education helps develop the skilled workforce businesses need, while transport investment helps firms move workers and goods. Business growth can then generate tax revenue to fund public services.
Government also encourages smaller Indian businesses through Startup India, reducing taxes and paperwork to make investment easier. Private investment therefore includes domestic firms, not just foreign TNCs.
Overall, India’s changing economy has increased opportunities for growth, employment and technological development. The strongest judgement is nevertheless qualified: gains are uneven, and pollution, insecure work and regional inequality can accompany rising national income. The balance between public and private investment matters because business growth alone does not guarantee that all communities benefit.
Before 1991: licensing restrictions made private investment difficult.
After 1991: economic opening increased private investment; US and European businesses outsourced manufacturing and IT work to India.
Overall judgement: sector change and investment support growth, but their benefits must be weighed against pollution, insecure work and regional inequality.
Distinguish a sector’s share of GDP from its share of employment. A smaller GDP share does not necessarily mean that total output has fallen.
Explain impacts through a chain: a change creates an opportunity or problem, which then affects people, places or the environment.
For an assessment, weigh positive and negative impacts using India-specific evidence, then give a supported judgement.
Public investment means government investment, not investment by members of the public. Private investment includes smaller businesses as well as TNCs.
Use 1991 as the turning point in India’s investment policies, but do not suggest that private investment replaced all government investment.
It can see this note and what your specification asks for.
Answers are free with an account.
1 free note left this week
Get more free notesYour answer sets when this note comes back for review, or marks it complete.
Was this note helpful?
Log in to tell us whether it helped, or to report a problem.
Last updated
Primary sector
Economic activity that obtains raw materials from the natural environment, such as farming, fishing and mining.
Secondary sector
Economic activity that manufactures goods or constructs buildings and infrastructure.
Tertiary sector
Economic activity that provides services, such as retail, transport, healthcare and banking.
Quaternary sector
Knowledge-based economic activity involving research, information technology and the development of new ideas.
Gross domestic product (GDP)
The total value of goods and services produced within a country over a given period, usually a year.
Investment
Spending on assets, infrastructure or skills intended to provide future benefits.
Public investment
Investment by government, for example in transport, education, healthcare or housing.
Private investment
Investment by businesses rather than government, including smaller firms and transnational corporations.
Transnational corporation (TNC)
A business that operates in more than one country.
Mechanisation
The use of machinery to carry out work previously performed by people or animals.
Formal employment
Registered and regulated work in which earnings and business activity are subject to taxation.
Informal employment
Work outside the formally registered and regulated economy, often without employment benefits or secure conditions.
Put your knowledge into practice — try past paper questions for Geography A
Primary sector
Economic activity that obtains raw materials from the natural environment, such as farming, fishing and mining.
Secondary sector
Economic activity that manufactures goods or constructs buildings and infrastructure.
Tertiary sector
Economic activity that provides services, such as retail, transport, healthcare and banking.
Quaternary sector
Knowledge-based economic activity involving research, information technology and the development of new ideas.
Gross domestic product (GDP)
The total value of goods and services produced within a country over a given period, usually a year.
Investment
Spending on assets, infrastructure or skills intended to provide future benefits.
Public investment
Investment by government, for example in transport, education, healthcare or housing.
Private investment
Investment by businesses rather than government, including smaller firms and transnational corporations.
Transnational corporation (TNC)
A business that operates in more than one country.
Mechanisation
The use of machinery to carry out work previously performed by people or animals.
Formal employment
Registered and regulated work in which earnings and business activity are subject to taxation.
Informal employment
Work outside the formally registered and regulated economy, often without employment benefits or secure conditions.